Skip to main content
University
of
Nebraska–Lincoln
Log In
Search
Search
Submit
Close
Midwest Roadside Safety Facility
Menu
Search
Log In
Home
Who We Are
History
Faculty/Staff
Employment
Contact Us
Services
Testing
Finite Element Analysis
Design/Consulting
Pooled Fund
About
Member States
Active Projects
Members Only
Tech Transfer
Newsletters and Featured Research
Research Hub
AFB20 (user/password required)
Pooled Fund Q&A
Q&A Home
Ask a Question
Search Questions
Q&A Reports
Login
Q&A Home
Ask Us A Question
Search Answered Questions
Q&A Reports
Login
Nebraska
MwRSF
Q&A Home
Seach Q&A
View Q&A
View Q&A
Steel Specifications for Guardrail Posts
Question
State
NE
Description Text
MwRSF has received multiple questions referring to the steel specifications and grades for guardrail posts. The Barrier Hardware Guide lists multiple steel specifications for standard guardrail posts: ASTM A36, ASTM A709 grade 36, and A709 grade 50. Additionally, the drawing details for many new systems are specifying the use of ASTM A572 and/or ASTM A992. Are all of these steel specifications considered equivalent, or which specification should be utilized for guardrail posts?
System Performance Evaluation
System Types
Road Closure Gates
Thrie Beam Guardrails
Applications
System Features
Date
December 22, 2016
Previous Views (132) Favorites (0)
Response
Response
(active)
Over the bast few decades the standard steel specifications for rolled structural shapes has changed. The older steels with yield strengths of 36 ksi have been replaced with higher strength materials with Fy = 50 ksi. Please refer to the attached documents describing this transition.
There is a lot fo overlap between these material specifications which allows for a particular steel lot/heat/batch to qualify under multiple of these specifications. For example, A36 requires only a minimum yield and tensile strength, there is no maximum values. As such, it has been easier to manufacture steel at grade 50 and label it as A992, A572, and A36. It may still be possible to obtain grade 36 steel posts, but it becoming increasingly difficult to find. Over the past 5-10 years, MwRSF has typically received A572 or A992 when ordering guardrail posts (even when A36 was requested).
The performance of standard guardrail systems should not be negatively affected by this change. Systems designed and tested with 36 ksi steels should still be crashworthy utilizing 50 ksi steel posts. However, there is a possibility for increased deck damage from bridge rails designed/tested with 36 ksi steel. The increased strength of the post will transfer more load to the deck. Damage to the deck would also depend upon the deck strength, concrete strength, and rebar configuration, so increased damage is not a certainty. Increased deck damage is a concern and systems specifying A36 posts should be evaluated on an individual basis.
Within drawing sets and system details, MwRSF has been listing multiple specifications as equivalent steel materials for use as guardrail posts. However, we have made the decision to stop listing grade 36 steels in current and future projects due to a lack of 36 ksi steel availability. MwRSF will only be listing grade 50 steel (A992).
ASTM 709 is available as a grade 50 steel, but A709 was developed for use on bridges. Accordingly, standard roadside and median barrier systems will likely not require A709. Instead, A992 is a better steel specification for these in-ground installations. Agencies may desire to utilize A709 in bridge rails. Thus, it should remain a viable option for use in bridge rail components with attention being given to ensure the proper grade is utilized to match the desired strength of the post/system.
This change is steel materials should also be reflected in the Barrier Hardware Guide. These recommendations will be given to Task Force 13 in hopes that the specifications within the guide can be updated to reflect current material standards.
Date
December 22, 2016
Previous Views (132) Favorites (0)
Attachment
Steelwise February 2012 (A992) .pdf
Attachment
Are You Properly Specifying Materials_ Part 1(2).pdf
Attachment
ASTM - A992.pdf
Some parts of this site work best with JavaScript enabled.